As already demonstrated with Speed Racer i often disagree with critics on the quality of movies but with The Spirit is appears im not only disagreeing with critics but also the majority of viewers. The Spirit, at the time of writing this, is scoring, on metacritic, a 31 out of 100, the same score as Max Payne(except the spirit ei a zero from one publication, a feat in the world of shit that not even max payne earned!). I personally feel that this is one of the most under-rated films of the year.
To start of I realize this movie indeed has some major flaws. For instance I wanted to kick every single actress in the mouth because each time their mouths opened, you knew you were in for a blizzard of shitty acting. The Spirit also overly used the meeting with death idea; The spirit meets with her(note: Its a her, yes! i wanted to kick her aswell!) like 3 or 4 times, the final resulting with the spirit being underwater, meeting with her, and deciding to go on living… which happened in Max Payne… they were almost the exact same scenes… didnt one person involved with the movie see max payne and think “boy! this movie is awful. waitaminute…FUCK! WE SHOT THAT LAST FRIDAY! I NEED TO WARN THE OTHERS!”? The final qualm I had with this film is that…it felt like Miller 100%, while stylistically it was quite good, it just didnt feel like eisner at all. But while these problems were quite annoying the film was still pretty damn enjoyable.
The Spirit’s main strength was Gabriel Macht(the spirit) and Samuel L Jackson(the octopus) when together and Louis Lombardi(the os henchmen) in general. The fight scenes between the octopus and the spirit had really good action and tended to be hilarious and the henchmen… well they were just plain funny, especially their various names(my personal favorites were huevos and rancheros). The quality of these 3 actors more than, in my opinion, the god-awful actresses.
The movie was also good in noir terms aswell. For instance EVERYTHING the spirit says is SO GODDAMN HARD BOILED! The spirit had the archetypal relationship with the chief, you know the “DAMNIT! GET IT IN ORDER OR ILL HAVE YOUR BADGE!” which the movie was happily lampooning and praising at the same time. The movie also had a collection of femme fatales… hot hot ANNOYING AS FUCK femme fatales including the nazi Japanese assistant and the gold-digger jewl theif.
I found the movie to be truely enjoyable and think that the only possible reason asto why its being slammed so hard is because people either misunderstand it or theyre being cockbags who review the movie because they saw other people hating the movie, cause golly who needs the truth when you can fit in!
I think this movie was misunderstood. People saw Frank Miller and instantly 300 and Sin City popped into peoples mind, giving them thoughts like “ima see me some gore” or “ima see me some bare-chested men!” and what they got was a noir comedy… except they didnt realize it was a comedy…and the people who showed up probably didnt even know what noir was. Now this may just seem like im saying “its bad on purpose” but trust me, i think every BAD about this movie is BAD and should not have been BAD and the director wasnt intending it to be BAD(dead lord I cant type BAD without capitalizing it!), what I am saying is that this movie is being looked at the wrong way. people expecting an action flick got a comedy and if you think that doesnt matter than imagine how a person who was told hotel rwanda was a comedy would rate it after seeing it.
Some of the flaws people have been pointing out are just plain silly to bring up. For instance a few people on IMDB got pissed off about how they couldnt tell what age it was because it had modern devices but an old car…except its only one car…and its own by extremely rich eva mendez… BECAUSE NO RICH PERSON OWNS A COLLECTOR CAR! thats like seeing a rich person drink an aged wine and saying “WAITAMINUTE! I THOUGHT WE WERE IN MODERN TIMES! WHATS ALL THIS TIME TRAVEL BUSINESS?!?!?!”. People have liked to take pot shots at Miller calling him racist which is why he made samuel l jackson speak in ebonics, eat fried chicken, drink kool-aide, and have several children from several women! These kinds of complaints shows that people really are just hating the movie for any reason they can think of.
In the end the movie was okay. Im tired of all this bullshit from professional critics. The Dark Knight gets overly praised cause its what “everyone” else liked while movies like speed racer and the spirit get smashed cause “everyone” hates it. sure the movie has some flaws but 31 on metacritic? thats just unacceptable! I get the feeling critics saw the first 10 or so minutes then copy-pasted other reviews.